Okay, this took a little longer than I’d anticipated. Having first examined the pitchers, we now turn our attention to the position players.
Catcher
There are two huge positional mismatches in this series, and catcher is the first. Padres catchers led the NL with 31 homers and were second to the Atlanta Braves with 107 RBI. As a unit, they hit .300/.362/.509. The Cardinals, meantime, had one of the biggest black holes of any team at any position in baseball this year behind the dish, hitting a combined .221/.277/.328.
Padres
By picking his spots, manager Bruce Bochy (a former catcher) was able to get the most out of veteran Mike Piazza, who caught just 99 games for the Friars in 2006. Piazza responded by hitting .283/.342/.501 in 399 at-bats. His defensive deficiencies are overblown, with the only real problem being that he bounces almost all of his throws to second base (he nailed just 12% of would-be base stealers). Piazza appears to have a good rapport with his pitching staff and does a nice job blocking the plate. Primary backup Josh Bard came over from Boston because he couldn’t catch Tim Wakefield’s knuckleball. Thankfully for the Padres, Bard does just about everything else very well. He hit .333/.404/.522 in 231 at-bats (including 18 AB with the Red Sox) and removed any temptation Bochy might have had to overwork Piazza. With Piazza basically catching three games out of every five and Bard taking the other two, there wasn’t much playing time for Rob Bowen. That said, Bowen had his uses, namely pinch running and/or coming in to replace Piazza behind the dish late in games. He hit .245/.339/.394 in 94 at-bats on the season. Almost all of his damage was done before the All-Star break, as Bowen hit just .188/.264/.313 in 48 second-half at-bats.
Cardinals
Yadier Molina and ex-Padre Gary Bennett did almost all of the catching for St. Louis in 2006, with Molina getting the bulk of the work. Molina hit an unbelievable .216/.274/.321 in 417 at-bats, but provided steady defense. An anti-Piazza of sorts (don’t forget the pepperoncinis!), Molina nailed 44% of runners attempting to steal against him. Bennett did his usual yeoman’s work behind the dish (although he threw out a mere 10% of potential base stealers) and hit .223/.274/.331 in 157 at-bats.
First Base
The Padres were in the bottom third in terms of production at first base, hitting .299/.358/.494. The Cardinals have the best hitter in baseball manning the position, and it shows. St. Louis first basemen hit a combined .325/.416/.641.
Padres
Local product Adrian Gonzalez, in his first season with the Padres and his first full season in the big leagues, saw nearly all the action at first base this year. An unknown coming into the season, Gonzalez took permanent control of the job when Ryan Klesko went down with injury. Gonzalez possesses a sweet left-handed swing that allows him to hit for a high average and drive the ball out of all parts of the park. He led the club with a .304 batting average and 24 homers, and finished third with 82 RBI (just one behind club leaders Mike Cameron and Brian Giles). Gonzalez ended up with a solid .304/.362/.500 line and was equally effective at home or on the road, as well as facing left-handed or right-handed pitching. He was a steady presence in the lineup, which you wouldn’t necessarily expect from a first-year player. In the field, Gonzalez features soft hands, terrific footwork around the bag, and strong baseball instincts. He won’t get serious consideration because he’s new to the league and he plays in San Diego, but Gonzalez is a Gold Glove caliber defender at first base in the vein of, say, Wally Joyner or J.T. Snow.
Cardinals
How do you analyze Albert Pujols? He’s the best hitter in baseball. Sorry, that’s all I’ve got. No, wait. He’s the best hitter in baseball and it’s not close. Also, don’t pitch to him with the game on the line. Dude is sick with the stick, dig?
Second Base
This is one of the most evenly matched positions in the series. Both San Diego and St. Louis were below average at second base, with the Padres hitting .274/.315/.415 at the keystone corner and the Cards checking in at .263/.326/.375.
Padres
Josh Barfield enjoyed a fine rookie campaign, hitting a solid .280/.318/.423 in 539 at-bats and playing better defense than we expected. That said, at 23 years old, he remains a work in progress. He’ll sit against tough right-handers in favor of the veteran Todd Walker (.278/.356/.398 in 442 AB), who was acquired from the Chicago Cubs in a deadline deal. Neither Barfield nor Walker is a guy you bank your hopes and dreams on, but they get the job done.
Cardinals
Aaron Miles, Ronnie Belliard, and Hector Luna all split time at second base. Belliard (.272/.321/.401 in 548 AB with Cle and StL) provided most of the offense, while Miles (.263/.324/.347 in 426 AB) was more of scrappy utility type guy. Luna was shipped to the Indians for Belliard at the end of July. Presumably Belliard will see most of the action this post-season.
Third Base
The hot corner (or “not” corner as we like to call it in San Diego) is the other positional mismatch. For the season, San Diego third basemen were the least productive in the NL, batting just .230/.304/.356. The scary part is that, due to a couple of late acquisitions, those numbers are much better than they were a month and a half ago. The Cardinals, meantime, were among the best at the position, with a combined .305/.379/.554 line.
Padres
Vinny Castilla was brought in to shore up a position that had been disastrous in 2005. Remarkably, he made it even worse, hitting .232/.260/.319 in 254 at-bats before being released mid-July. Another off-season acquisition, Mark Bellhorn, took over from Castilla and was nearly as bad, finishing up with a .190/.285/.344 line in 253 at-bats. Todd Walker was brought in to replace Bellhorn but hadn’t played the position in eight years and, despite producing at the plate, had problems throwing the ball to first base. Finally, Russell Branyan came over from Tampa Bay and took the job, hitting .292/.416/.556 in 72 at-bats with San Diego. It says something about how desperate the situation was that Branyan, who only joined the club on August 24, accounted for 40% of the Padres’ home runs at the position. Geoff Blum also saw some time at third (as well as at shortstop and second base).
Cardinals
Scott Rolen bounced back from an injury-plagued 2005 and once again did a great job at the plate and in the field. (Incidentally, how come all the Comeback Player of the Year talk centers around Nomar Garciaparra and nobody’s paying attention to this guy?) Rolen hit .296/.369/.518 in 521 at-bats, and when he wasn’t out there, Scott Spiezio was picking up the slack quite nicely, batting .272/.366/.496 in 276 at-bats while filling in as needed at the infield corners, in left field, and occasionally even at second base. Not bad for a guy who went 3-for-47 over the entire 2005 season.
Shortstop
Neither team’s shortstops set the world on fire. The Padres hit .239/.302/.397 at the position, while the Cardinals batted .290/.350/.361. The starters for both clubs missed time due to injury, forcing reserves into more expanded roles.
Padres
Khalil Greene teased at various points in the season, most notably by hitting .361/.400/.619 in 97 July at-bats. Unfortunately, he injured a finger and went 3-for-36 with no extra base hits over the final two months to finish at .245/.320/.427. For the second straight season, Greene played in exactly 121 games and for the third straight season, he hit exactly 15 home runs. Consistency isn’t always a good thing. Geoff Blum (.254/.293/.366 in 276 AB) saw most of the time at shortstop in Greene’s absence, with Manny Alexander getting into a handful of games as well. Blum is susceptible to sliders down and in, and is limited defensively, but could come in handy if the Padres need a pinch hitter in the 14th inning.
Cardinals
David Eckstein bugs the heck out of me because he doesn’t play for my team. He’s the new Craig Counsell. Nothing about Eckstein suggests that he should be able to start at the big-league level except for the fact that he does. He hit .292/.350/.344 in 500 at-bats and continued to put absolutely every ounce of available energy into his throws to first. Aaron Miles filled in while Eckstein was on the shelf fom mid-August to mid-September.
Left Field
In what is becoming a familiar refrain, both clubs finished near the bottom of the pack at this position. The Padres left fielders hit .275/.340/.386 (the only team in the league not to clear the .400 SLG mark), while the Cards’ posted a .273/.344/.434 line.
Padres
Dave Roberts again provided a spark at the top of the San Diego lineup in 2006. Roberts hit .293/.360/.393 on the season and stole a career-high 49 bases in 55 attempts. Despite enjoying considerable success against lefties as well as righties, he often sat against southpaws, first in favor of veteran Eric Young (.203/.281/.313 in 128 AB with SD, but great “clubhouse presence”), then in favor of youngster Ben Johnson (.250/.333/.425 in 120 AB). Roberts, who had been overmatched as an everyday center fielder in 2005, showed much better instincts and generally looked more comfortable in left.
Cardinals
St. Louis didn’t really have an everyday left fielder. Rookie Chris Duncan (162) had the most at-bats among Cardinals who played the position in 2006, but several others saw significant time there as well. Duncan hit .293/.363/.589 in 280 at-bats, playing both corner outfield spots and also seeing some action at first base. Defensive specialist So Taguchi (.266/.335/.351 in 316 AB), lefty-swinging John Rodriguez (.301/.374/.432 in 183 AB), and the aforementioned Scott Spiezio were the other chief left fielders this season.
Center Field
Both teams feature marquee players who are, or should be, entering the decline phase of their careers. The Padres got terrific production at the position, with a combined line of .262/.347/.460. St. Louis, on the other hand, enjoyed slightly less success; its center fielders batted .252/.336/.404.
Padres
Mike Cameron, acquired in an off-season deal with the New York Mets, returned to the scene of a gruesome injury incurred in 2005 and responded with a big season for the Padres in spacious Petco Park. Cameron started all but a handful of games in center for San Diego, finishing with a .268/.355/.482 line and 25 steals in 34 tries. He established career highs in base hits and slugging percentage, and tied career highs in doubles and triples. Cameron also played Gold Glove caliber defense, giving the Padres their first true center fielder since Mark Kotsay departed following the 2003 season.
Cardinals
Jim Edmonds missed much of the season’s second half due to “post-concussion syndrome” but was effective when healthy, posting a .257/.350/.471 line in 350 at-bats. Those numbers are well below his usual standards, but they’re still pretty darned good. One thing Edmonds didn’t do well at all in 2006 was hit left-handers (.156/.198/.281 in 96 AB). So Taguchi and Juan Encarnacion (.278/.317/.443 in 557 AB), both right-handed hitters, also saw time in center.
Right Field
Once again, the Padres and Cardinals are in the lower half at this position. San Diego’s right fielders batted .263/.371/.398 on the season. Only the Florida Marlins and Philadelphia Phillies saw their right fielders knock fewer home runs. The Cards, meantime, hit a combined .272/.323/.469.
Padres
The days of Brian Giles being a dominant offensive force are long gone. His primary value now derives from being able to get on base, drive the occasional double into the gaps, and play Petco Park’s troublesome right field corner with grace and skill. Giles hit .263/.374/.397 in 604 at-bats and there is talk of moving him into the leadoff spot next year if Dave Roberts doesn’t return. Giles remains a tough out but more of a table setter now than a middle-of-the-order type.
Cardinals
Juan Encarnacion logged most of the time in right field for St. Louis. He was pretty much the same player in 2006 that he’s always been — reasonably good at many things, great at none. Doesn’t get on base much, but can pop one out of the yard every once in a while. Would it be fair to call him a poor man’s Raul Mondesi? Yes, I believe it would.
Whew, I’m beat. I’m sorry; could you repeat the question?
Recent Comments