In-Game Discussion: Padres vs Mariners (26 Jun 2005)

first pitch: 1:05 p.m., PT
television: Channel 4
matchup: Woody Williams (3-5, 4.13 ERA) vs Joel Pineiro (2-4, 5.57 ERA)
previews: ESPN | CBS | Padres.com

I was running around town yesterday so I only got to listen to Saturday’s 8-5 victory over the Rainiers on the car radio. Now that I’ve seen highlights on TV, I have three thoughts (which is three more than I usually have):

  1. Those throwback unis the Pads wore are sweet. I wouldn’t mind seeing the guys bust those out again sometime.
  2. How in the heck did Xavier Nady hit that pitch out to left field? How did he hit it out, period?
  3. After so many no-decisions earlier in the season, it was good to see Jake Peavy get a little help from his offense. Peavy didn’t have his best stuff yesterday but thanks to homers from Nady, Khalil Greene, and Mark Sweeney, and a two-run double (to right no less) off the bat of Sean Burroughs, the Padres ace was able to pick up the W.

Also, I got to wondering if Peavy’s struggles might have been related in some way to the high pitch count of his previous start, but the available evidence doesn’t really support that theory. Here are all the starts in which Peavy has thrown 120+ pitches (white), followed by his subsequent start (grey):

Date Opp IP H R ER HR BB SO Pit
5/11/03 @NYN 6.1 7 2 2 1 5 6 128
5/16/03 Atl 6 7 4 4 2 2 5 110
9/7/04 StL 5.1 8 4 3 0 3 8 124
9/12/04 @Col 8 7 2 1 1 1 8 98
9/17/04 @SF 7 8 4 4 1 3 7 121
9/22/04 LA 8 3 2 2 0 1 11 114
6/20/05 LA 8 2 0 0 0 1 13 124
6/25/05 Sea 5 7 5 5 1 2 3 102

I still would prefer not to see a whole lot of those starts. OTOH, when you consider that only 4 of his 91 career starts falls into that category, it’s not so bad.

Sunday afternoon marks the finale of interleague play (remind me again why they do this now?). Two veteran right-handers go at it:

                               AB   BA  OBP  SLG

Williams vs current Mariners  150 .253 .341 .427
Pineiro vs current Padres      58 .224 .250 .328

I will be out at today’s affair. Enjoy the game, and let’s take the series!

60 Responses »

  1. More on Nady playing time. Geoff did an analysis of Nady as a starter vs. bench player. That got me thinking: what about him getting regular playing time vs. being “rusty”. This led me to categorize his AB’s into four categories: regular vs. rusty and bench vs. starter.

    To set the criteria of “regular” I initially said, “3 games in a week”. These initial results were a bit surprising:

    Starter, Regular (SReg)
    Games: 20; AB: 75; OPS: .763

    Starter, Rusty (SRust)
    Games: 12; AB: 38; OPS: .886

    Bench, Regular (BReg)
    Games: 6, AB: 8; OPS: 1.150

    Bench, Rusty (BRust)
    Games: 11, AB: 13, OPS: 1.005

    Regular: G: 26, AB: 83, OPS: .802
    Rusty: G: 23, AB: 51, OPS: .917

    Hmmm. Looks like Nady does best with rest, and is an especially good bench player.

    I then expanded the criteria to be 4 games in a week.

    SReg: G: 16; AB: 61; OPS: .901
    SRust: G: 16; AB: 52; OPS: .695
    BReg: G: 3; AB: 2; OPS: .333
    BRust: G: 14; AB: 19; OPS: 1.139

    I pushed it up to 5, and nubers even skew more towards Nady being a starter, but that is most likely an artifact of reducting the sample. To deal with the start of the season and latest AB (where I could not look back or forward to see his playing time to determine the “week”) I counted all the games in Colorado at the start of the season as a regular, and counted the latest two starts as a regular (with both Nevin and Roberts hurt that has to be the case). Sadly, outside those two cases, there are not enough games where he got 5+ starts in a week.

    So he does well as a rusty bench player, but you do see some noticeable splits between his “regular” starts (OPS: .901) vs. “rusty” (OPS: .695), using the 4 games a week criteria. Play him regularly, and he plays better. If .900 OPS is his “regular starter” OPS, he becomes the best hitter on the team.

  2. Nice top of the first inning. Living in SF, I get almost all my games via MLB Extra Innings, which does not include Cox, but does include Fox. Apparently Fox is on the Nady bandwagon; when showing our defensive set up, they showed Nady in left and center; they also showed Loretta at second. Wishful thinking.

    I like Williams start. Just bringing fastballs. The fouls got some pitches off his arm, but he was not going to walk anyone or try to get too deep in counts.

  3. Looks like I am chatting by myself. Normally I watch the games after they are over (via Tivo) but am watching it only slightly delayed. Damian. Nice jack. 3 outs followed, but Sweeney, Klesko and Giles all swung at strikes, went reasonably deep in the count, so OK AB’s.

  4. For some reason I really like this lineup

  5. I’m here. Kind of listening to game in and out.

  6. I’m here for a few minutes … I got a 421 tee time @ Torrey Pines North … lookin’ forward to it …

    Here’s pitching #s thru 3.5 …

    Pitches-strikes – J Pineiro 55-38; W Williams 62-38.

    Ground balls-fly balls – J Pineiro 5-3; W Williams 3-6.

    Batters faced – J Pineiro 13; W Williams 14.

  7. I gotta whine about Bochy still putting Burroughs ahead of Nady in the lineup … whassup with that? There’s just no reason … there’s barely reason for Burroughs to be in the lineup at all!

  8. Reed makes good catch on weak flair bat of Burroughs … the guy can’t even get lucky!

  9. That was smoked by X

  10. Nady just hit the f’n building. Wow!

  11. Nady … DONG … DONG … DONG …DONG … DONG … DONG …DONG … DONG … DONG …DONG … DONG … DONG …DONG … DONG … DONG …DONG … DONG … DONG …DONG … DONG … DONG …DONG … DONG … DONG …DONG … DONG … DONG …DONG … DONG … DONG …DONG … DONG … DONG …

    into the upper level of the WMS building ….

  12. M’s score … Boone with shot to LF …

  13. What’s with DJ? 3 for 3 with a home run.

  14. Nady’s only the third player to hit a ball into the top shelf of the Western Metal Supply Co. Building (Khalil hit two and Miguel Cabrera one).

  15. Why not let Mark Sweeney swing the bat?

  16. Wow. That was an amazing play by Boone.

  17. Boone starts highlight-reel 4-6-3 DP :-(

  18. That was completely sick by Boone. Jeez.

  19. He’s one of the top 20 defensive second baseman of all time…

  20. Williams: 5.0 IP, 3 H, 1 R, 0 BB, 5 K, 1 HR (77 Pitches, 49 Strikes)
    PiƱeiro: 5.0 IP, 7 H, 4 R, 0 BB, 2 K, 2 HR (88 Pitches, 60 Strikes)

  21. Is he really?

  22. Padre hitters today: .350/.333/.700

  23. The Fox guys were saying some scouts think he’s the best. He ain’t.

  24. I’ll second it … perhaps Top 10 …

  25. that play by boone is the reason why the Padres wanted sweeney to bunt. second and third with one out means ground ball or long fly out scores a run, which is moot after the doubleplay.

  26. Kevin … what’s your concern? Who’s better defensively?

  27. In Bill James’ Win Shares, he rates everyone defensively and gives Boone a B-. That would not put him in the top 20. I don’t think it would be him anywhere near it.

  28. Sorry I havent posted more but I hate to come in here and start bubbling all over the page. I am feeling really good since the Padres started getting some offense going..

  29. That’s for career. I based the top 20 comment on a players’ best five consecutive years. Mazeroski was the best…

  30. Boone’s in the top ten that I’ve found the numbers for, but I feel like I’m probably missing a few.

  31. all this talk about Young coming back and taking over at 2nd prolly has gotten DJ a little scared for his spot on the roster. I think he is making a statement today…

  32. Right, that is for career. But Boone’s best five year’s were that great, I don’t think. Maybe they were. Joe Morgan used to gush over him, but I didn’t buy it. Of just the post-War second baseman, 21 received A’s from James. That’s not even counting the B+’s and B’s.

  33. Joe Morgan was better than Boone, too.

  34. I was also using Fielding Runs Above Average, not Fielding Win Shares.

  35. According to BP, the Wild Card now projects to require more wins than the NL West…

  36. Morgan gets a C from James. But I didn’t see him that much.

  37. Without Boone this game is a rout

  38. Good thing we let Woody finish the seventh.

  39. Rivera with 3-run shot … tie game … 4-4

  40. That was Woody’s 103rd pitch …

  41. I dont believe Woody hung a curve to that kid. Geesh.. He is far too experienced to pull something like that, especially after the way he has handled the kid today.

  42. Would anyone here have pulled Woody? I know I wouldn’t have… Just damn.

  43. Yeah, I agree with what that guy said. Boone was celebrated as a great defender in Cincinnati, and that was a litte out of whack. And there’s no way he can be as good now, because of age.

    Plus, it’s nice that that guy listed HOF second baseman, but many of the best are not Hall of Famers. For example, Frank White is one of the top five or so.

    Here are the post-War guys James list as “A” fielders: Jerry Adair, Bobby Avila, Marty Barrett, Scott Fletcher, Nellie Fox, Bobby Grich, Glenn Hubbard, Bobby Knoop, Mike Lansing, Mark Lemke, Jose Lind, Bill Mazeroski, Jody Reed, Jackie Robinson, Red Schoendienst, Ted Sizemore, Rennie Stennett, Snuffy Stirnweiss, Manny Trillo, Fernando Vina, Frank White, Rob Wilfong.

  44. I’ve never been too big of a fan of Win Shares when comparing players from different seasons…

  45. Really, I thought that was supposed to be the strength of Win Shares?

  46. They’re not really going to blow this game… Are they?

  47. Nady can pick it too!