Jeter Is Out of Position, Everyone Screws Up, and Still the Yankees Find a Way to Win

This morning I am a Mariners fan. Give the Yankees credit, they are incredible opportunists. The A’s gave them an opening and the Yanks closed it in a New York minute.

The key turning point definitely was in Game 3, when Jeremy Giambi was thrown out at the plate on a truly bizarre play. Aside from the fact that this kept the A’s from tying the ballgame, symbolically the play told us everything we need to know about both franchises. Yankees right fielder Shane Spencer airmails two cutoff men, and Derek Jeter, hopelessly out of position, makes a spectacular catch and flip to Jorge Posada to nail Giambi.

Almost everybody screwed up on that play, and the Yankees were rewarded for it, while the A’s were punished. Spencer overthrows Alfonso Soriano, who has abandoned second base to take the throw, which is correct. But Spencer also misses Tino Martinez, who is backing up Soriano. Enter Jeter, who by all rights should be covering second in case Soriano or Martinez cuts the ball off and tries to nab Terrence Long going for two. Despite Joe Torre’s assertions to the contrary, there is absolutely no reason for Jeter to be where he was. Unless someone is going to tell me that this is a set play, where the right fielder intentionally misses two cutoff men to try and lull the runner heading toward the plate into a false sense of security. With apologies to Spinal Tap, it’s such a fine line between clever and stupid.

At any rate, on the Oakland side, Giambi fails to slide. On the one hand, I can almost see what he’s thinking: how in the heck did the ball even get to Posada? On the other, the on-deck batter, Ramon Hernandez, was in better position to see what was happening out in the field and motioned for Giambi to get down. If there’s even the possibility of a play at the plate, the runner has to slide.

Sliding on the play has two effects. First and foremost, it gives the catcher a harder target. I’d have to watch the replays again, but my suspicion is that if Giambi slides past the plate and reaches back with his hand, he scores. Or at the very least, and this is the second factor, he makes it more difficult for the home plate umpire to call him out. I really don’t understand Giambi’s decision not to slide unless (a) he was stunned that there was even a play or (b) he’s not very good at that particular skill. Ultimately, neither is excusable from a professional in that situation (not to pin all the blame on Giambi; this was a turning point, but he didn’t lose the series by himself — Oakland’s futility at the plate with runners in scoring position and complete defensive collapse in Game 5 probably were more damaging in any tangible sense).

What a frustrating end to an otherwise brilliant season for the A’s and their fans. What a frustrating chapter for all of us who are loathe to see the Yankees in yet another World Series.

Go Mariners!

A’s and Yankees in Playoffs, Padres Prospects

How about those A’s? Start calling Tim Hudson “Iceman” if we aren’t already. The guy is unflappable. Every team wishes they had a guy like that on their staff. Unreal.

How about Jason Isringhausen? Again. Handed a 2-0 lead to start the bottom of the ninth, he allows a leadoff squib double down the left-field line to Bernie Williams and a walk to Tino Martinez. With runners at first and second, nobody out, Izzy catches Jorge Posada looking at a fastball on the outside corner for strike three, then induces David Justice and Scott Brosius to hit weak popups on the infield to end the game. Yes, the playoffs are a different animal. But Isringhausen doesn’t seem to appreciate the difference. He and Jason Giambi actually managed to share a laugh when the latter visited the mound during Posada’s at-bat. And the Yanks are the ones who are supposed to be playoff-savvy?

Speaking of the Yankees, are those announcers getting kickbacks from Steinbrenner for saying nice things about his team? Yeah, they give the A’s some credit but for the most part, the Fox guys are making excuses for the Yankees and talking about what they need to do to get out of this funk they’re in. Uh, guys, here’s an idea: They need to play a team that isn’t significantly better than them. Yep, I think that might get them out of their little funk. It will be interesting to see if the announcers stop gushing over the Yankees once they’re out of the playoffs. I’m not optimistic.

The New York media are cute, too, trying desperately to fire up their club. I tell ya, where’s Jeffrey Maier when you need him? He could turn things around. Jeffrey Maier. Now there’s a man of action.

Good to see the Mariners win. They and the A’s have to meet in the ALCS. Actually, if there were any justice, those two teams would meet in the World Series. As it is, if they do meet, the World Series might actually be something of a letdown.

Back to the media, you know who’s impressed me at Baseball Tonight? Guest analyst Al Leiter. Not that I thought he’d be an idiot or anything, but when you’re constantly presented with guys like Rob Dibble and Ray Knight, well, let’s just say they lower the bar of expectation just a tad. And Leiter’s still actually playing baseball. Yeah, he sometimes resorted to cliches but for the most part he gave good explanations of what the pitcher was thinking and what he was throwing. And he didn’t butcher the English language or come off as a pompous ass. Maybe someone can get him to coach Dibble and Knight?

In other news, Josh Boyd over at Baseball America reports that the Padres are now talking about trying Jake Gautreau at second base. With Xavier Nady’s bum elbow keeping him out of Instructional League (and probably limiting him to DH the first half of 2002) and the Burroughs/Nevin situation unresolved, Gautreau will get the next shot. After a slow start in the Northwest League, the Padres’ first-rounder out of Tulane finished strong, and even played well in a cameo at Triple-A Portland after Burroughs went down to injury. I’m hoping I’ll get to see Gautreau at Elsinore next year, but I have a feeling he may jump straight to Double-A. If he does come to the Cal League, look for him to put up Nady-like numbers — maybe higher batting average and not quite so many homers.

Good article on Mark Phillips over at TeamOneBaseball.com.

And in the AFL, not a lot going on for Padres prospects. Outfielders Darren Blakely (.333/.556/1.000 in 6 AB) and Kory DeHaan (.310/.310/.724 in 29 AB) are doing well, as is lefty Eric Cyr (6 IP, 5 H, 3 BB, 7 SO, 1.50 ERA). Righty J.J. Trujillo isn’t having as much success (3.2, 7, 1, 6, 7.36).

I saw Blakely when he was at the University of Hawaii, and again when he played for Elsinore. Great athlete with inconsistent baseball skills. Probably a fourth outfielder at best, and that’s assuming he learns to control the strike zone. A few other big names on that Peoria squad: Hank Blalock (3B, Tex), Drew Henson (3B, NYA), Kevin Mench (OF, Tex). And one of my favorites, Seattle farmhand Craig Kuzmic. Playing mostly first base and some second, Kuzmic is hitting .429/.520/.857 in 28 at-bats. He could be a pesky little utility infielder in the bigs if given the chance.

Links and Thoughts on the Playoffs

Apologies for the sporadic updates. Four-hour computer classes Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday night; in-laws in town. I can barely think. Of course, that won’t stop me from spewing. ;-)

A few links:

Okay, next order of business: Big thanks to Jay-Dell Mah of AtThePlate.com fame for plugging my site. If you haven’t been to over to AtThePlate, I highly recommend you do so asap. Jay does a great job of covering minor-leaguers all year long. An excellent resource.

Playoffs

Hard to get into it too much when your team doesn’t make it. Again. Not that I’m complaining about the Padres’ season. But I do find myself more rooting against, rather than for, teams. I’d just as soon not see the Astros or Diamondbacks go to the World Series, mainly because of their managers. Larry Dierker for not pitching to Barry Bonds and almost costing his team a shot at the playoffs (does anyone else appreciate the irony of the Astros being beat because Dierker broke character and let his guy pitch to Chipper Jones in the first game?). Bob Brenly because there’s no crying in baseball. Although I must confess, I almost felt bad for him when Miguel Batista went into ultra brain lock last night. Almost.

But I could even live with Houston or Arizona making it to the World Series. The Yankees, on the other hand, are another matter altogether. It’s gotten to the point where I don’t even hate them anymore; I’m just mostly indifferent, to the point where I generally won’t even watch a game on TV if they’re playing.

Jeffrey Maier, Richie Garcia. Disgraceful, yes; but not really the Yankees’ fault. Broadcasters apologizing to viewers and the Yankees for not providing a more worthy opponent than the Padres in 1998; again, not the Yankees’ fault. But combined, enough of a reason not to watch them on TV. Maybe with the volume off. Or in the ninth inning, like last night, when I did get to hear Tim McCarver explain that Jason “2.65 ERA” Isringhausen had a shaky year and that the playoffs were a different animal, or some such nonsense. David Justice, strikeout swinging; Scott Brosius, weak fly to right; Alfonso Soriano, strikeout swinging (and it wasn’t close). Yup, a different animal it is. Woof!

On the (somewhat) bright side, it was like watching the Padres back in June. Woody Williams (gotta love him) shut down the Diamondbacks and outpitched Randy Johnson to steal a game in Arizona and even the series. How sweet was that? Then it was Sterling Hitchcock and Jay Witasick helping the Yankees lose to Oakland. Awesome.

Bonds and Mariners Break Records, Henderson Chases 3000, Gwynn Nears End

It just keeps getting better. Barry Bonds breaks Mark McGwire’s record for homers in a season, the Mariners break the Yankees’ AL mark for victories in a season (with Jamie Moyer, age 38, becoming the oldest player to win 20 games for the first time), Bud Selig visits San Diego to congratulate and thank Tony Gwynn. Heck, even Lenny Harris tied Manny Mota’s record for most career pinch-hits yesterday, at 150.

We were at the game last night (pix later), and got to watch the Rickey Henderson chase for 3000 first-hand. We also saw baseball honor two of its true heroes, with a whole brigade of elected officials from the city, the county, the state, and even Mexico congratulating Henderson and Gwynn for their achievements. Mayor Dick Murphy named yesterday Rickey Henderson Day and this week Tony Gwynn Week. Selig came out and did a surprisingly good job of not ruining the moment, even noting Tony’s commitment to San Diego in taking over as coach at SDSU in 2003.

After the pregame festivities, a moment of silence — save for a couple of barking police dogs and one idiot a few seats down who couldn’t spare even a few precious seconds of talking on his cell phone to remember our fellow countrymen.

Then came the game, and a great deal of futility on the home squad’s part against rookie RHP Jason Jennings. The youngster pitched six shutout innings but didn’t look overpowering, although he did show the ability to work his way out of trouble. His fastball ran 90-92, and he consistently worked up in the strike zone, a bit surprising for someone who calls Coors Field home. Jennings complemented the fastball with a nasty slider that hitters were chasing even when he was behind in the count, and a decent change-up. We sat along the right-field line, at a pretty severe angle, so I didn’t have the best view of Jennings, but generally speaking he reminded me a bit of a young Andy Benes.

As for the Henderson, the closest he came to a hit was when he hit a rocket to the left of second baseman Jose Ortiz, who somehow managed to snag it on one hop and throw Rickey out by plenty. The crowd gave Rickey a standing ovation every time he stepped up to the plate, and the folks out in the left-field bleachers cheered wildly each time he took his position in the field. For as vilified as he has been over the years in some circles, Rickey has been nothing but a positive influence here in San Diego, and he has been a fan favorite during both stints with the Padres.

Gwynn made his lone trip to the plate with one out in the bottom of the ninth, pinch-hitting for Cesar Crespo. He grounded Jose Jimenez’ second pitch to Ortiz for an out number two. The crowd gave Tony a standing ovation as he approached the plate, after he was announced, and again as he trotted back to the dugout.

It’s so easy to be cynical about baseball, with all the big money and big egos involved. But last night, watching Tony one final time, and seeing clips of him on the big screen between innings, when he was truly a brilliant player who could do almost anything on a baseball field, I was reminded of why I love this game. Every clip of Gwynn showed him in a Padres uniform (yes, even the Ray Kroc hamburger-and-mustard unis from the early-80s), and I guess we here in San Diego maybe have taken Tony for granted over the years, as if there were some law of physics that kept him in this city.

But there are no natural laws that describe Gwynn’s presence in San Diego. There is only Tony. It was by choice — a choice that wasn’t always popular with some close to him (or the union), who thought he could make more money playing elsewhere — that he remained a Padre. It’s difficult for someone like me to think seriously of sacrifice when speaking of millions of dollars, but given his milieu, Gwynn did make sacrifices to remain in San Diego. And even now, as plays his final homestand, we know he will be here next year, just up the hill, coaching as an unpaid volunteer his alma mater, in a stadium bearing (despite Tony’s protests) his name.

. . .

I hope all the idiots out there who have been bad-mouthing Bonds for so long will finally start giving him the credit he is due. For a guy who generally has been an upstanding — if aloof and downright surly at times — citizen, he has gotten may too much grief from a bunch of embittered old writers for no apparent reason other than he didn’t kiss their asses or give them neatly wrapped sound bites for their columns. Sad to say, this begrudging of Bonds as a personality, as a human being, has extended to Bonds as a player, and there are those who would advocate Sammy Sosa as a more worthy MVP candidate this year, who would tag Bonds with the label “choker,” who would dismiss the notion that Bonds is one of the top three or four players ever to set foot on a baseball field. To those people I suggest finding a different line of work. Anyone who has followed his career and objectively measured all that he has accomplished in this game understands Bonds’ place in history. Anyone who fails to recognize his greatness really shouldn’t refer to themselves as a baseball writer. It’s embarrassing to Bonds, to the game, to themselves, and to their employer.

Baseball is, and always has been, a team sport. The goal is to win games and ultimately the championship. In the time leading up to his breaking of McGwire’s mark and even during the ceremony after the game (the one image that always will remain with me is that of Bonds goofing around with his youngest daughter, who is sitting on his lap while Paul Beeston sings her father’s praises), despite our nation’s fixation on an individual record, Bonds continually has asserted that winning is what matters. For a guy as allegedly self-centered and arrogant as Bonds, the guy has a desire to win that cannot be questioned. He puts, as the Vulcans would say, the needs of the many ahead of the needs of the few. Sure, the guy can be a jerk at times but I defy you to find me someone — anyone — for whom the same cannot be said. But he understands what the game is about, he respects the game, and he plays it with great intensity and skill. And he really wants to win. I don’t know about you but that’s the kind of guy I want on my team. Every time. Congratulations on a great season, Barry. And I sure hope you get that ring you deserve before you call it a career.

Henderson Breaks Cobb’s Career Runs Scored Record, or Does He?

Great day for baseball yesterday: The Tim Raineses play side-by-side in the Baltimore outfield, Barry Bonds ties Mark McGwire’s single-season home run record, and Rickey Henderson breaks Ty Cobb’s career mark for runs scored. Or does he? Almost every source available credits Cobb with 2246 runs.

You know what else is funny? Cobb is almost universally credited with 4189 hits. Maybe my mind is playing tricks on me, but didn’t Pete Rose break Cobb’s record of 4191 hits?

Well, I put in a call to the Office of the Commissioner of Baseball, and a very patient young woman confirmed the discrepancies, and said that Elias Sports Bureau is the official keeper of records for MLB and that sometimes the old records aren’t entirely accurate.

So I called Elias, and they claim that someone at SABR went back and found a game (in 1912, I believe) where Cobb wasn’t credited with a run and should have been. The gentleman I spoke with also said that when Elias looked through all the records, they found that the single run added was balanced out by another run that was improperly added to Cobb’s record at some other point. He also suggested that MLB and various other sources are receiving faulty information from whomever maintains the databases that contain all this information. Why Elias isn’t providing these databases is beyond me, but that, in a nutshell, is the scoop.

So, Rickey either broke or tied Ty Cobb’s mark for runs scored yesterday at the Q. And tonight he has the chance to either break or extend the record (I’ll be there, so I was kinda hoping they screwed up and Rickey would pass Cobb tonight). Whatever happens, there’s a good chance we’ll never know how many runs Cobb really scored.

Henderson Passes Cobb

Well, he (Rickey) did it: Henderson passes Cobb to become all-time runs leader

I was really hoping he’d hold out for one more day (we have tickets for tomorrow night’s game), but I’m just happy he got the record. Maybe he’ll get his 3000th hit tomorrow. That would be cool…

Articles Worth Reading

A few articles worth reading:

Baseball America’s Top 20 Prospects by League for 2001

Baseball America has done their top 20 prospects for each minor league. The Padres are well represented:

  • Pacific Coast League. #1 Sean Burroughs, 3B; #20 Cesar Crespo, UT.
  • Southern League. #6 Dennis Tankersley, RHP.
  • California League. #1 Dennis Tankersley, RHP; #2 Xavier Nady, 1B; #5 Jake Peavy, RHP; #8 Ben Howard, RHP; #16 Ben Johnson, OF; #18 Eric Cyr, LHP.
  • Midwest League. #18 Oliver Perez, LHP.
  • Northwest League. #5 Jake Gautreau, 3B; #9 Jason Bartlett, SS; #13 Justin Germano, RHP.
  • Pioneer League. #3 Josh Barfield, 2B.

Off-hand, I’m a bit surprised that Burroughs and Germano were ranked so high, and that Peavy and Perez were ranked so low. The latter two, as well as LHP Mark Phillips, who didn’t make any top 20 lists, were hurt by the fact that they split time between two or more leagues this year.

Looking back at my top 25 Padres prospects I see a few things I’d like to change. Rating LHP Mike Bynum at #7 was probably a mistake. I gave him too much credit for being closer to the bigs than guys like Perez and Cyr. Barfield might have been a tad low, Sain a tad high (probably my USD bias). Cyr and Germano may be too low, too, although I worry about the former’s off-the-field troubles.

And now for something completely self-indulgent: <voice="DonPardo">If I Ran the Padres.</voice>

Okay, here’s what I’d do. First, much as it pains me, I’d deal Phil Nevin. Get some good, young, cheap players for him, preferably guys up the middle. The Braves want to move Chipper Jones to the outfield, so they would seem to be a good candidate, right? So maybe move Nevin for Wilson Betemit, Odalis Perez, and a second-tier prospect or two — say Ryan Langerhans and Matt McClendon. Stick Perez at the back of the rotation or use him as a swingman, and let Betemit learn second base at Portland — he’ll be ready to take over for Damian Jackson by August at the latest.

Here’s how I’d build the lineup:

  1. Sean Burroughs 3b
  2. D’Angelo Jimenez ss
  3. Ryan Klesko 1b
  4. Bubba Trammell rf
  5. Ray Lankford/Mike Colangelo lf
  6. Mark Kotsay cf
  7. Ben Davis c
  8. Damian Jackson/Wilson Betemit 2b

Or, if leading off Burroughs is too radical, swap him and Kotsay. Maybe move Davis up a slot to break up the lefties. Honestly, if the Pads don’t deal Nevin this winter, I don’t see how they’re going to accommodate everyone. And you sure as heck can’t send Burroughs back to Portland. Nice problem to have, though…

Padres Extend Trammell

The Padres’ signing of Bubba Trammell is interesting. On the one hand, $9M for 3 years seems reasonable for a 28-year-old corner outfielder with career .267/.342/.481 numbers. On the other hand, he isn’t good enough to build around, and his qualitative stats have suffered this year with increased playing time.

Another wrinkle is the Sean Burroughs factor. With Burroughs likely taking over at third next year, Phil Nevin would move to first, which would push Ryan Klesko to right and create a Ray Lankford/Trammell platoon in left. But I don’t believe Kevin Towers would drop $3M a year for a part-time player, so I’m guessing he’s figured he can’t afford to re-sign Nevin. At the very least, he’s given himself and the Padres a little insurance.

And now for the latest on next year’s rotation:

  1. Bobby Jones
  2. Kevin Jarvis (assuming he re-signs)
  3. Brian Lawrence
  4. Brian Tollberg
  5. Junior Herndon/Jason Middlebrook/Brett Jodie/Dennis Tankersley

I suspect that with so many options at the back end, the Pads will elect to start Tankersley at Triple-A. My guess is that Middlebrook or Jodie will win that fifth starter assignment: Middlebrook because he’s the oldest, Jodie to justify the Hitchcock deal. Whoever wins that spot will be about two bad starts from losing his job.

Speaking of Tankersley, Baseball America reports that he has been compared to Kevin Brown by some Southern League observers. I’m not sure about that, but I do believe he has a chance to become the pitcher Pads’ fans were expecting Matt Clement to be. Tankersley has that kind of stuff but with much better command.

Nevin, Nady, and Bonds

  • Phil Nevin has rejected the Padres offer of $32M for 4 years. He’ll probably get more, and it probably won’t be in San Diego. Both sides remain optimistic, but I have my doubts we’ll be seeing Phil in a Pads’ uniform next year.
  • Xavier Nady won’t be working out at second base this off-season. Instead, he’ll be undergoing and recovering from surgery on his right elbow. He first injured the elbow in the Arizona Fall League last year, and it never fully recovered. Gotta like a guy who plays hurt and still wins his league’s MVP award.
  • Bonds battles hostility in his pursuit of history (ESPN.com). Is there anybody more in need of a life than a guy who shows up to sporting events to heckle a professional athlete? (Well, unless that guy is me and that athlete is Hideki Irabu. In my defense, calling Irabu “professional” is a bit of a stretch.)
  • Behind the Numbers: Bonds and the Babe (CBS SportsLine). Jason Beck takes a look at Bonds’ assault on the Babe’s single-season ISO (SLG – BA) record. Bonds currently is at .513.
  • Here’s a site calling for the firing of Toronto GM Gord Ash. At first I thought this was that wacky Canadian humor, but they appear to be serious. Heck, they even have a petition.