Padres and Rangers Make Minor Deal

The Padres have traded former “center fielder of the future” Freddy Guzman and right-hander Cesar Rojas to the Rangers. I first saw Guzman play at Lake Elsinore in 2002 when he still was known as Pedro de los Santos — one of the most electric players I’ve seen in the Cal League. Unfortunately he’s 25 years old and his only real tool is speed. Lots and lots of it. Guzman projects as a fourth outfield type. The Padres have plenty of those, so off he goes to Texas.

Coming to San Diego are right-hander John Hudgins and first baseman Vince Sinisi. Both are former top prospects whose stock has fallen. Neither is particularly young or projects to be an impact player, but both could be useful, particuarly Hudgins, who has seen significant action in the high minors and could come up in a support role at some point.

Hudgins was the Rangers’ third round pick in 2003 out of Stanford. Baseball America had him ranked #21 among Texas prospects in 2004, #6 in 2005 (#5 was a guy named Chris Young), and #19 this year. Reports have his fastball in the 87-91 mph range, topping out at 93. His curve is average, and his best pitch is “a sinking changeup that he sells with grunts and late violence in his delivery.” BA calls him a potential #5 starter. Not exciting, but potentially useful. Temper your enthusiasm by recalling that Brett Jodie also was “potentially useful.”

Sinisi was drafted one round ahead of Hudgins in 2003 out of Rice. He has been hurt for much of his pro career and never really developed as expected, particularly in the power department. In their 2004 Prospect Handbook, Baseball America notes that “Sinisi reminds scouting director Grady Fuson of Jason Giambi, who was drafted by the A’s when Fuson was their national crosschecker in 1992, at the same stage.” Sinisi was ranked #5 in 2004, #10 in 2005, and #18 this year. At age 24 and with minimal experience above Class A ball, he’s probably not a future regular.

In this year’s book, BA says that “Sinisi can hit line drives to all fields and knows the strike zone” and that “his smooth lefthanded stroke is tailored to hit doubles in the gaps.” Sinisi played the outfield in college, though it’s not clear how much experience he has there as a pro. Doesn’t sound like a threat for an everyday job in the big leagues anytime soon, but could be a useful bat off the bench in, oh, a Todd Sears kind of way.

Both are potentially more valuable to the Padres than was Guzman, who arrived on the scene with his speed game about 20 years too late. Then again, as a buddy of mine wisely pointed out, this deal could be a whole lot of nothing. We’ll see.

8 Responses »

  1. Not thrilled w/ either guy we got, or either guy we gave up. Rojas could become something someday but he’s certainly not giving ANY evidence to say we should keep him.

    Your Sinici comments are spot-on – AAAA guy. Hudgins now… who knows, spot starter, innings muncher, career 23rd-4th-5th guy on the roster who won’t embarrass you out of the pen… Not a sexy trade but Guzman wasn’t going to supplant Camron and how valuable is a late-20′s AAA CF without a lot of hitting ability?

  2. With space cleared on the 40 man roster, anyone think Leone’s name might be added? And, since Bowen might be headed to the d/l for 15 days, could it be they are thinking of give said Leone an audition at 3b? Hmmmm

    Certainly is something to think about.

  3. btw, with btb multi hit games, it would appear that Leone’s slump might be over.

  4. well looks like Braz booked a ticket out of town with that smelly job last night. Jon Adkins is coming back after not allowing a run since reporting back to the Beavers.

    The U/T is speculating that PMac or Cust could be called up if Bowen has to go on the d/l

  5. Adkins over Sikorski? Adkins has 11 strikeouts in 12 innings, and that’s nice, but Sikorski has 40 strikeouts in 24 innings. 40!

    I count only 37 names on the roster.

  6. I don’t know why they won’t promote Sikorski. It’s not like Adkins was all that great when he was up briefly before. If we end up losing Sikorski to some stupid contract clause, it just shows that even though Alderson and Fuson are here, some things in the front office remain business as usual.

  7. Sinisi…..SinISi…..I’m going to have fun with this name…

    Fairwell Frederick….