From the Vault: Be Careful What You Wish For

[In honor of Hideki Irabu's retirement announcement, I thought it would be appropriate to re-run the article that started it all here at Ducksnorts (we're talking pre-blog days). In a very minor and tangential way, Irabu helped pave the way to Petco Park. One of the players acquired in the deal that sent The Fat Toad to the Yankees was Rafael Medina, who in turn was part of the payment for Kevin Brown, who helped lead the Padres to the 1998 World Series, which helped get the new stadium funded and built. Also, according to some sources Irabu was born on the exact same day as I was, so I like to think of him as my evil twin. This was originally published September 6, 1997. I don't think I could write this article today. If I did, I wouldn't include the references to Richard Nixon or terrorists, and the tone generally would be less melodramatic. But a lot changes in 7 1/2 years, and there it is. I've added a few links in the article and at the end as well; otherwise everything remains as it did back then. Enjoy!]

It was just a matter of time before Hideki Irabu and George Steinbrenner discovered what the rest of us already knew: that even under the best conditions, making the transition from the Chiba Lotte Marines to the New York Yankees would be difficult. Under the conditions that Irabu set for himself, however, it has been darned near impossible. In a display of two-facedness that would have made the late Richard M. Nixon proud, Irabu humbly stated his dream to play baseball professionally in the United States; then, when it became evident that his dream would be realized via the San Diego Padres, he and his agent, Don Nomura, suddenly changed their tune.

What Irabu had meant to say, so the story goes, was that he had dreamed of playing for the Yankees. Apparently his dream included visions of himself making outrageous demands of his prospective new employer and insisting he would not work unless those demands were met. Perhaps this is unfair of me, because I’ve never been a terrorist, but it seems that the only careers in which this type of behavior is tolerated and too often rewarded are terrorism and professional sports. I can count on one finger the number of seconds I would remain employed were I to place such demands on my employer.

Irabu’s crowning achievement came when he compared San Diego to a prison camp. I have lived in San Diego for several years, and although I have never been incarcerated, I like to think that my present living conditions are significantly better than those of a prison (unless I was in for tax evasion or embezzlement or something and got to watch TV and play golf all day).

Regardless the respective merits of San Diego and a prison camp, Irabu had made it quite clear to everyone that he had no intention of playing for anyone but the Yankees. So the Padres, not being complete idiots, cut their losses and, with the blessing of Chiba Lotte, dealt him to the Bronx Bombers for Rafael Medina, Ruben Rivera, and $3 million. The Yankees then, after lengthy negotiations, signed Irabu to a very generous long-term contract.

The general assumption was that the out-of-shape Irabu would zip through the minors and come up in time to help the Yankees defend their status as “World Champions.” And sure enough, he abused hitters at the A, AA, and AAA levels, all the while attracting more and more media and fan interest as “the next [Hideo] Nomo, only better.” He finally made it to the major leagues and struck out nine Detroit Tigers in his debut.

But already opponents questioned his ability, much as his own teammates had previously questioned his right to pitch for the Yankees. Mr. Steinbrenner dismissed Irabu’s detractors as jealous naysayers. Boss George claimed to lose respect for David Justice after the Indians’ slugger called the pitcher’s stuff “average.” Meanwhile, the hefty hurler continued his downward spiral, each start worse than the one previous.

The Yankees then decided his mechanics needed to be fixed, so they sent him back to the minors for a couple starts. Again, he pitched well.

When Irabu returned to New York, he arrived with Yankee minor league pitching instructor Billy Connors, who would serve as a sort of personal coach. Irabu, mechanics allegedly fixed, took the mound again with the same approach as before his demotion and the same predictable results: Fall behind in the count with the forkball, leave the fastball (92 mph, rather than the 99 mph he had allegedly been clocked at in Japan) out over the plate, look out for falling objects.

After a start at Oakland, in which Irabu faced a less-than-formidable lineup and allowed three homers in three plus innings, manager Joe Torre called his performance unacceptable in the context of a pennant race [Ed note: I believe I was at this game; one of the few times I've ever actively booed a professional athlete]. Torre gave him one more start, this time against the lowly Philadelphia Phillies. Irabu never made it out of the fourth inning. Steinbrenner, who had been sitting in the front row to watch his prize pitcher ignite yet another bonfire at the expense of a possible return to the World Series, left the stadium soon after Irabu left the playing field and later blasted him, calling him, as Brian Hunter and David Justice had before, overhyped and suggesting that he needed to learn how to pitch and stop blaming everyone and everything else for his own personal failures. Irabu, meanwhile, declined to speak with reporters, choosing instead to spend some quality time with breakable objects in the visitor’s clubhouse.

The jury is still very much out on Hideki Irabu. Forty-something innings aren’t nearly enough to make a sound judgment on his status as a major league pitcher. But the early returns are, to put it delicately, less than favorable. Many young men have great “stuff” but possess the mental toughness of strawberry Jell-o. Irabu, with his fan-spitting, glove-throwing, clubhouse-sprinkler-breaking antics (to say nothing of his body), is resembling a considerably fouler flavor. And right now he’s probably wondering what he ever did to deserve this. And how much nicer a prison camp would be.

Additional sources:

2 Responses »

  1. When it was announced that Irabu was going to take a shot at the majors, my reaction at the time was “gulp!”

    Having seen Irabu pitch while he was with Lotte, he had the stuff to succeed and the high 90′s clockings he garnered were legitimate (his high was 158km/h, or 98mph, a record that wasn’t eclipsed until Seibu Lions ace Daisuke Matsuzaka, who will open 2006 in the Bronx, registered 100mph (160km/h) during the Athens olympics).

    However, he also had substantial makeup problems. To be frank, I didn’t think he was ready from a maturity standpoint. I was right, especially when he began fighting with the Padres about being a Yankee.

    I recently talked about Irabu with a well known baseball player agent and he agreed with me that Irabu would have been better off in a relatively more pressure free San Diego rather than the media hothouse that is New York. Yanks pitching coach Mel Stottlemyre also altered Irabu’s mechanics and “the jellyfish,” as he was nicknamed in Japan, never looked comfortable with the new form, especially as it resulted in a dropoff in velocity.

    After being cut loose by Texas, Irabu returned to Japan, had a successful 2003 with Hanshin, but got hammered in the Japan Series and couldn’t get anyone out after that as well and was released him at the end of the 2004 schedule. Nobody else was interested and presumably he will retire to L.A., where he has a home with his wife and daughter (Irabu has a green card).

    By the way, here is a little scoop for you Padres fans: they will be scouting Softbank Hawks catcher Kenji Johjima, Japan’s Gary Carter, this season with an eye to perhaps bidding for him when he becomes a free agent at season’s end. However, they also don’t want to layout big bucks for him. Johjima currently makes about $5 million a year.

    Matsuzaka is being deemed too expensive for their taste, especially since Yankees VP Gene Afterman has firmly stated (while somehow avoided tampering allegations) that the Yankees will be all over Matsuzaka when he is posted.

  2. Great stuff, Gary. Thanks much for the info!